Volume 13 Supplement 2
Health care provider knowledge and routine management of pre-eclampsia in Pakistan
© The Author(s). 2016
Published: 30 September 2016
Maternal mortality ratio is 276 per 100,000 live births in Pakistan. Eclampsia is responsible for one in every ten maternal deaths despite the fact that management of this disease is inexpensive and has been available for decades. Many studies have shown that health care providers in low and middle-income countries have limited training to manage patients with eclampsia. Hence, we aimed to explore the knowledge of different cadres of health care providers regarding aetiology, diagnosis and treatment of pre-eclampsia and eclampsia and current management practices.
We conducted a mixed method study in the districts of Hyderabad and Matiari in Sindh province, Pakistan. Focus group discussions and interviews were conducted with community health care providers, which included Lady Health Workers and their supervisors; traditional birth attendants and facility care providers. In total seven focus groups and 26 interviews were conducted. NVivo 10 was used for analysis and emerging themes and sub-themes were drawn.
All participants were providing care for pregnant women for more than a decade except one traditional birth attendant and two doctors. The most common cause of pre-eclampsia mentioned by community health care providers was stress of daily life: the burden of care giving, physical workload, short birth spacing and financial constraints. All health care provider groups except traditional birth attendants correctly identified the signs, symptoms, and complications of pre-eclampsia and eclampsia and were referring such women to tertiary health facilities. Only doctors were aware that magnesium sulphate is recommended for eclampsia management and prevention; however, they expressed fears regarding its use at first and secondary level health facilities.
This study found several gaps in knowledge regarding aetiology, diagnosis and treatment of pre-eclampsia among health care providers in Sindh. Findings suggest that lesser knowledge regarding management of pre-eclampsia is due to lack of refresher trainings and written guidelines for management of pre-eclampsia and presentation of fewer pre-eclamptic patients at first and secondary level health care facilities. We suggest to include management of pre-eclampsia in regular trainings of health care providers and to provide management protocols at all health facilities.
KeywordsCommunity health services Eclampsia Health personnel Pre-eclampsia Community health worker Pregnancy Pakistan
Plain english summary
High blood pressure in pregnancy is one of the major three causes of maternal deaths in Pakistan. Different research studies have shown that health care providers have limited knowledge regarding management of these patients. In this study we explored knowledge of community and hospital based health care providers regarding causes, complications and treatment of the disease. Doctors, Lady Health Workers, Lady Health Supervisors and traditional birth attendants were interviewed in groups and one to one in Sindh province. Along with interviews Lady Health Workers were also asked to fill a questionnaire to assess their competency and knowledge. Study found that community based health care providers consider stress and physical work load a cause of high blood pressure. Only doctors were aware of the first line medicine to treat severe cases of high blood pressure in pregnancy but they were concerned regarding the safety of drug to be used in small health facilities. Regular trainings of care providers are required to improve their knowledge and practices to deal with pregnant women with high blood pressure.
Pre-eclampsia is defined as development of new hypertension in pregnancy along with significant proteinuria occurring after 20 weeks of gestation . It is a multisystem disorder that may affect the liver, kidney and clotting in pregnancy, as well as potential fetal growth restriction and premature delivery . Eclampsia is a complication of pre-eclampsia defined as the new onset of grand mal seizure(s) and/or unexplained coma during pregnancy or postpartum in a woman with pre-eclampsia . Eclampsia is responsible for one in ten maternal deaths, and claims 2000 maternal lives every year, in Pakistan [3, 4].
Several multicounty trials [5, 6] and systematic reviews  have proved that MgSO4 is an important agent in the management of severe pre-eclampsia and eclampsia. The World Health Organization (WHO) stated that MgSO4 is the first line drug for treatment of pre-eclampsia and eclampsia more than a decade ago  and Pakistan included MgSO4 in the national essential drug list in 2007 . However, these efforts have not translated into practice and a large number of women continue to suffer from pre-eclampsia and eclampsia without receiving life-saving treatment.
In Pakistan, the health care system is comprised of both formal and informal sectors. Formal system included public and private health facilities. Pakistan’s public health system is centralised under the Federal Government and Provincial Health Ministries; and comprises of primary, secondary and tertiary health centres. Primary care facilities include 5000 Basic Health Units, 560 Rural Health Centres, 900 Maternal and Child Health centres and large number of dispensaries and first aid posts. Secondary level centres include 900 Taluka and district level hospitals. Tertiary health care is delivered through 30 teaching hospitals .
Lady Health Workers (LHWs) and Lady Health Visitors (LHVs) are deployed as community-based health care workers in the home and primary health centres . Doctors and nurses are deployed at all levels of health care facilities. The private sector consists of a few accredited tertiary level hospitals and a large number of non-accredited tertiary, secondary and primary clinics and hospitals both in urban and rural areas. The informal health care system is led by non-certified local health care providers, such as traditional birth attendants (TBA), spiritual healers, and Hakeems (practitioner of Unani/Greek medicine). The informal health care system is patronised by many as treatment is affordable, available within the local community, and in-line with traditional and cultural beliefs .
Studies from other low and middle-income countries (LMIC) reported that contrary to WHO guidelines, women were not regularly screened for high blood pressure during antenatal care . Literature from the developing world has also reported that various cadres of health care providers (doctors, nurses, midwife, and community care providers) have limited knowledge regarding screening and management of pre-eclampsia [13–15].
The limited knowledge of health care providers likely plays a role in the slow reduction in maternal morbidity and mortality due to pre-eclampsia in developing countries, such as Pakistan. Hence, we explored the knowledge of different health care providers regarding pre-eclampsia and eclampsia and their current management practices in rural Sindh, Pakistan.
Comparison of population characteristics of Sindh Province with country estimates
The Community Level Intervention for Pre-eclampsia (CLIP) study is a cluster randomized trial which is being conducted in two districts of Sindh Pakistan (NCT01911494). Before implementation of the trial, a feasibility study was conducted to evaluate barriers and facilitators of providing emergency treatment in community to women who are at high risk of severe pre-eclampsia. Lady Health Workers were chosen to deliver this intervention to pregnant women as they are responsible to provide antenatal care at home in rural areas. Intervention package includes triage and screening of pregnant women for risk of severe PE/E, administering oral antihypertensive and MgSO4 (if required) and referral. It was important to understand the existing practices and knowledge of health care providers regarding PE/E. We evaluated health care providers involved in maternal care whether they were community based (LHW, LHS, TBAs) or health facility based (Doctors). The feasibility assessment utilized mixed methods . and intervention implementation plan was modified according to the findings of the feasibility study.
The qualitative research team organised the conduct of focus groups and interviews. Gender specific staff was allocated with respect of local culture and tradition. Project staff were locally recruited and trained by a senior faculty and a social scientist with first-hand knowledge and expertise in qualitative research. Each focus group was conducted in the local language by one facilitator, two note takers, an observer and all discussions were audio-recorded. Observers documented field notes to capture verbal and non-verbal communication in support of the documented text. In addition, the facilitators completed a self-reflection after each session to describe their thoughts and impressions to better contextualize the data, as well as, to protect against self-bias. Quality control was ensured through random observation of focus groups by the field co-ordinator, and an audit-trail of 20 % of transcripts. The audit-trail process included verifying content of transcripts with audio-recordings, and bi-weekly debriefing sessions with moderators and transcribers. The field staff then transcribed the data in Sindhi based on the audio recordings. The qualitative data was analyzed in Sindhi using NVivo version 10 [QSR, Doncaster Vic, Australia] to develop the themes and subthemes from an ethnographic approach.
Health care provider interviews and focus groups
Health care providers
Total number of interviews/discussions
Total number of participants
Women Medical Officer/Gynaecologist
Lady Health Supervisor
Traditional Birth Attendant
Lady Health Worker
Eligible participants were identified with the help of local community health workers and research medical officers during health facility visits. Written consent was obtained from all participants prior to data collection.
A self-administered questionnaire was completed by 457 LHWs, all questions were designed using a Likert scale (strongly disagree to strongly agreeThe knowledge of LHWs regarding pre-eclampsia was evaluated by a set of questions pertaining to their ability to identify danger signs of hypertension and seizures in pregnancy. Their current practice of referral and skills to administer drugs were also evaluated.
This study received ethical approval from Ethics Review Committee of Aga Khan University, Karachi, Pakistan; National Bioethics Committee of Pakistan and Institutional Review Board of University of British Columbia, Vancouver Canada.
Among health care providers who participated, all were providing care to 3–5 pregnant women daily for more than a decade, except one TBA and two doctors. Six out of nine women medical officers (WMO) were providing care at the primary and secondary level public health facilities. About 6 pre-eclampsia or eclampsia patients (range 0–100 in last 12 months) were received by (WMO) in last 12 months. TBAs did not report encountering any women with pre-eclampsia in the last year. According to Lady Health Supervisors (LHS) on average 3 women with pre-eclampsia are reported to them per year by LHWs.
Knowledge regarding pre-eclampsia aetiology and consequences
“She looks after the children and again she gets pregnant. She has no such stamina (strength) to deal with the problems and that is the reason she also gets irritated, sometimes because of children, sometimes because of family problems and sometimes cause is financial problems. She starts thinking lot and her B.P starts to rise up”. (Focus group with LHWs)
“One cause of seizures is that they are pregnant and the other cause is that she is anemic and stressed out.”(Interview with a TBA)
“When blood pressure increases firstly it is dangerous for the mother, the mother can also die, even the baby can die, it can affect the mother in anyway, she can have paralysis, because of high blood pressure paralysis can occur.” (Focus group with LHWs)
Diagnosis and referral of pre-eclampsia
“If the woman is pre-eclamptic, we will tell them to visit us every 15 days. She should get her blood pressure checked and she should take medicines on time.”(Interview with a WMO)
“When she comes with eclampsia and if she is having seizures then we refer her because in our health centre we don’t have facility for C-section. If she is not in a good condition and is having seizures, we try to get her delivery done soon as possible. If she is not able to have normal vaginal delivery then we refer her.”(Interview with a WMO)
“Vomiting more than 3 months, slowly oedema starts, headache, having fever, bleeding during pregnancy then in that condition we refer to heath facility.” (Focus group with LHWs)
“We tell them that you must go for monthly or fortnightly check-ups to any good health facility which is in vicinity; go there and get your check-up.” (Interview with a TBA)
“Bone is short or large; (delivery) path is clear or not. Then we refuse to take case and advise them to get her to the hospital.”
“When we see that the fetal movements have stopped (in woman having fits), I ask the attendants to arrange the car quickly”. (Interview with a TBA)
“We will tell them to take her to the nearest hospital or clinic as soon as possible.” (Focus group with LHWs)
Management of pre-eclampsia
“No (we do not use), because it (MgSO 4 ) is not used at dispensary level.”
“MgSO 4 we don’t give here because we need a separate doctor to manage it.”
“We monitor the blood pressure, and try to refer the eclamptic woman to the Civil Hospital as early as possible.” (Interview with a WMO)
All doctors except one senior doctor, with greater than 25 years of experience, expressed a desire to learn more regarding the management of pre-eclampsia and argued there was a need for related guidelines. Participants stated that they infrequently encounter pre-eclampsia; therefore, they are not confident in managing these cases.
“We give it (Aldomet) daily if BP is high. We advise it twice a day or daily at night. The patient must eat daily so that the patient’s blood pressure remains normal.” (Interview with a TBA)
“We give 200, 250, grams Phakki, one spoon daily morning she is advised to take.” (Interview with a TBA)
Similar to doctors community-based providers have seen few patients with eclampsia in their practice; therefore, they were willing to learn more about the condition, its risk factors, prevention and treatment.
This study found gaps in knowledge among community health care providers regarding causes of PE/E and its management. Health facility based care providers were aware of the etiology and complications of the disease but there were misperceptions and limited knowledge about use of Magnesium sulphate.
Studies have reported a common community perception that seizures of eclampsia are caused by supernatural forces  and the frequent use of herbal medicine delays health care seeking . Community based care providers may not connect eclampsia and hypertension; however, none claimed to believe in evil charms or supernatural causes for the seizures and use of alternate medicine to treat eclampsia.
Pre-eclampsia is a serious condition, but because of the relatively low prevalence of the disease care providers had infrequent experience with these patients. This lack of exposure results in a reported lack of confidence in dealing with these patients. Pakistan has included current global management principles of pre-eclampsia in skilled birth attendants and nurses trainings , but in this study health care providers expressed desire for further training as they found current trainings insufficient. This finding is not consistent with Bigdeli’s findings from Pakistan that health care providers were satisfied with their training .
Data from other LMIC showed a preference for diazepam in cases of eclampsia  but in this study only two of the nine doctors mentioned regular use of diazepam. Despite prolific myths and fears related to MgSO4, no other drugs were preferred for treating eclampsia by the providers interviewed. This finding is consistent with another study on use of MgSO4 from Pakistan . The preference for MgSO4 is very encouraging as use of diazepam in eclampsia is harmful for both mother and baby. Health care providers in this study commonly reported referring women with pre-eclampsia and eclampsia prior to the administration of lifesaving treatment. Similar finding has been reported in literature . Explanations for this practice in Pakistan and elsewhere were related to the misperception that MgSO4 should only be used in tertiary level facilities . Other reasons MgSO4 was not administered were the lack of written treatment and referral protocols. The lack of clear guidelines to manage pre-eclampsia has been reported earlier as a barrier to health care provision at first and secondary level .
Other studies have also found that health care providers at high level facilities had better knowledge of pre-eclampsia [24, 25]. This might be due to more exposure of such cases and the availability of written protocols.
Strengths and limitations
Several studies have been published on barriers and facilitators to use MgSO4 in LMICs [14, 15, 26, 27]. This study explores significant aspects of management of pre eclampsia with respect to knowledge regarding disease, procedural ability, preference for use of drugs and clinical decision making of both skilled and unskilled care providers. Qualitative methods gave an insight to the misperceptions related to the condition and its treatment as health care providers were free to express their beliefs, fears and experiences. TBAs are preferred birth attendants for many rural women so it was important to evaluate their level of understanding for the disease. So far literature published from Pakistan on PE/E management only assessed practice of skilled care providers. Limitation of the study is that it did not inquire participants about management for severe pre-eclampsia and eclampsia separately therefore the study cannot determine the knowledge of health care providers for the prophylactic use of MgSO4 in severe pre-eclampsia. Future researches should explore ways to develop educational strategy and simple tools to empower first and second level health care providers to be able to approach obstetrical problems. This will help to expedite referral in rural pregnant women and initiating treatment in homes in severe cases which require urgent management even before referral. The curriculum for health care providers who are involved with pregnant women in communities should be reviewed and training should ensure acquisition of competency for dealing with obstetrical emergencies.
This study reveals that even in presence of a national policy supporting pre-eclampsia programmes, providers lack confidence and/or competence in treating these women. Gaps in the knowledge of aetiology, diagnosis and treatment of pre-eclampsia among all cadres of health care providers were seen. Findings suggest that limited exposure to pre-eclampsia cases, the lack of refresher trainings and no written guidelines for management of the disease are important factors leading to inadequate knowledge. We suggest inclusion of management of pre-eclampsia in regular training of all health care providers and to provide management protocols at all levels of health care. There is also need for strong advocacy for use of MgSO4 as emergency treatment before referral from first and secondary level health facilities for the best maternal and fetal outcomes.
Community level intervention for pre-eclampsia
Lady health supervisor
Lady health visitors
Lady health workers
Low and middle-income countries
Traditional birth attendants
World Health Organization
Women medical officer
This work is part of the University of British Columbia PRE-EMPT (Pre-eclampsia/Eclampsia, Monitoring, Prevention and Treatment) initiative supported by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. CLIP Working Group: Payne Beth, AinaOlabisi, Chomiak Marianne, Dada Olukayode A, Drebit Sharla, Firoz Tabassum, Goudar Shivaprasad, Kariya Chirag, Katageri Geetanjali, Lee Tang, Li Jing, Lui Man Sun, Makanga Tatenda, Ramadurg Umesh, Sharma Sumedha, Solarin Kunle, and Magee Laura A.
This article has been published as part of Reproductive Health Volume 13 Supplement 2, 2016: Building community-level resilience for the case of women with pre-eclampsia. The full contents of the supplement are available online at http://reproductive-health-journal.biomedcentral.com/articles/supplements/volume-13-supplement-2. Publication charges for this supplement were funded by the University of British Columbia PRE-EMPT (Pre-eclampsia/Eclampsia, Monitoring, Prevention and Treatment) initiative supported by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation.
RNQ was involved in the concept, design and execution of the study. She also contributed in writing and review of the manuscript; RAS, ARK, SZ were involved in the design and execution of the study; data collection. SS and MV contributed to the writing of the manuscript. DS, ZAB and PvD made significant intellectual contribution to the entire study. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
The authors declare no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.
Reviewer reports for this article are included in Additional file 2.
Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.
- National Collaborating Centre for Ws, Children’s H. Hypertension in pregnancy: the management of hypertensive disorders during pregnancy. London: RCOG press; 2010. NICE Clinical Guidelines, No. 107.Google Scholar
- Mattar F, Sibai BM. Eclampsia. VIII. Risk factors for maternal morbidity. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 1990;163:1049–55.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Saving mother’s lives in Pakistan. The White Ribbon Alliance; [October 10, 2013; cited 22 April 2014]; Available from: http://whiteribbonalliance.org/?s=Saving+mother%E2%80%99s+lives+in+Pakistan.
- Pakistan Demographic Health Survey 2006–07.
- Group TETC. Which anticonvulsant for women with eclampsia? Evidence from the collaborative eclampsia trial. Lancet. 1995;345(8963):1455–63.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Altman D, Carroli G, Duley L, Farrell B, Moodley J, Neilson J, et al. Do women with pre-eclampsia, and their babies, benefit from magnesium sulphate? The magpie trial: a randomised placebo-controlled trial. Lancet. 2002;359(9321):1877–90.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Lelia Duley AMG, David J Henderson-Smart and Doris Chou. Magnesium sulphate and other anticonvulsants for women with pre-eclampsia. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2010;11. doi:10.1002/14651858.CD000025.pub2.
- World Health Organization. Reproductive H. Managing complications in pregnancy and childbirth: a guide for midwives and doctors. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2003.
- National essential medicines list of Pakistan. Ministry of Health, Government of Pakistan; 2007 [updated 2007; cited 22 April 2014]; Available from: http://www.who.int/selection_medicines/country_lists/pak_EML_2007.pdf?ua = 1
- Siddiqui GK, Hussein R, Dornan JC. Dying to give birth: the Pakistan liaison committee’s strategies to improve maternal health in Pakistan. BJOG. 2011;118(s2):96–9.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Shaikh BT, Hatcher J. Health seeking behaviour and health service utilization in Pakistan: challenging the policy makers. J Public Health. 2005;27(1):49–54.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Plotkin M, Tibaijuka G, Makene CL, Currie S. Quality of Care for Prevention and Management of Common Maternal and Newborn Complications. USAID, MCHIP; 2013 [updated 2013; cited 2015 May 4, 2015]; Available from: http://www.mchip.net/sites/default/files/mchipfiles/Tanzania_%20QoC_StudyReport_FINAL_0.pdf
- Thein TT, Myint T, Lwin S, Oo WM, Kyaw AK, Myint MK, et al. Promoting antenatal care services for early detection of pre-eclampsia. SEAJPH. 2012;1(3):290–98.Google Scholar
- Bigdeli M, Zafar S, Assad H, Ghaffar A. Health system barriers to access and use of magnesium sulfate for women with severe pre-eclampsia and eclampsia in Pakistan: evidence for policy and practice. PLoS One. 2013;8(3):e59158.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Aaserud M, Lewin S, Innvaer S, Paulsen EJ, Dahlgren AT, Trommald M, et al. Translating research into policy and practice in developing countries: a case study of magnesium sulphate for pre-eclampsia. BMC Health Serv Res. 2005;5(1):68.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Hyderabad District, Sindh. 2014 [updated 2014; cited 27 Mar 2014]; Available from: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyderabad_District,_Sindh.
- Bhutta ZA, Memon ZA, Soofi S, Salat MS, Cousens S, Martines J. Implementing community-based perinatal care: results from a pilot study in rural Pakistan. Bull World Health Organ. 2008;86(6):452–9.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Khowaja AR. Methodology for assessing the feasibility of community level interventions for pre-eclampsia in South Asian and African contexts. Abstracts/Pregnancy Hypertension. 2015;5(1):53–156.Google Scholar
- Adamu A, Ekele B, Tunau K, Hassan M. Perception of relations of patients with eclampsia. Int J Gynecol Obstet. 2009;107(2):93–6.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Guerrier G, Oluyide B, Keramarou M, Grais RF. Factors associated with severe preeclampsia and eclampsia in Jahun, Nigeria. Int J Womens Health. 2013;5:509.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Jeffrey Smith SC, Julia Perri, Julia Bluestone, Tirza Cannon. National Programs for the Prevention and Management of Postpartum Hemorrhage and Pre-Eclampsia/Eclampsia; A Global survey 2012. USAID, MCHIP. 2012
- Kim YM, Ansari N, Kols A, Tappis H, Currie S, Zainullah P, et al. Prevention and management of severe pre-eclampsia/eclampsia in Afghanistan. BMC Pregnancy Childbirth. 2013;13(1):186.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Balancing the scales. Engender health; 2007 [updated 2007; cited 2012 13 Dec 12]; Available from: http://www.engenderhealth.org/files/pubs/maternal-health/engenderhealth-eclampsia-report.pdf.
- Jayanna K, Mony P, Ramesh BM, Thomas A, Gaikwad A, Mohan HL, et al. Assessment of facility readiness and provider preparedness for dealing with postpartum haemorrhage and pre-eclampsia/eclampsia in public and private health facilities of northern Karnataka, India: a cross-sectional study. BMC Pregnancy Childbirth. 2014;14(1):304.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Harvey SA, Ayabaca P, Bucagu M, Djibrina S, Edson WN, Gbangbade S, et al. Skilled birth attendant competence: an initial assessment in four countries, and implications for the safe Motherhood movement. Int J Gynecol Obstet. 2004;87(2):203–10.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Ridge AL, Bero LA, Hill SR. Identifying barriers to the availability and use of magnesium sulphate injection in resource poor countries: a case study in Zambia. BMC Health Serv Res. 2010;10(1):1.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Liljevik S, Lohre ESVB. Evaluation of knowledge and management practices of hypertension in pregnancy among health care workers in Moshi urban, Tanzania. [updated 2012. Thesis work. University of Oslo, Norway; cited 24 Aug 2016]; Available from: https://www.duo.uio.no/bitstream/handle/10852/29011/Prosjekt-Liljevik.pdf?sequence=3.
- Report On The Status Of Millennium Development Goals Sindh. United Nations Development Programme Pakistan & Government of Sindh. 2012.
- Sindh Health Sector Strategy 2012 – 2020. TRF, Government of Sindh, HSRU; [cited 2015 23 June 2015]; Available from: http://www.trfpakistan.org/LinkClick.aspx?fileticket=1EyZSVfIMkg%3D&tabid=2618.
- Jalal S. The lady health worker program in Pakistan-a commentary. Eur J Public Health. 2011;21(2):143–4.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar