Skip to main content

Table 4 Descriptive D&A results for all L&D observations from 40 health facilities in Malawi in 2013

From: The prevalence of disrespect and abuse during facility-based maternity care in Malawi: evidence from direct observations of labor and delivery

Direct clinical observation item

Number of observations

Number of occurrences

Frequency of occurrence

Non dignified care

 Did not respectfully greet pregnant womana

208

29

13.9%

 Shouted, insulted or threatened the woman during labor or afterc

2109

41

1.9%

Non consented care

 Manual exploration of uterus after delivery when unindicatedc

2109

2

0.09%

 Used episiotomy (without indication)c

208

1

0.50%

 Did not ask woman (and support person) if she has any questionsa

208

152

73.1%

 Did not ask client if there are any other problems the client is concerned abouta

203

150

73.9%

 Did not explain procedures to woman (support person) before proceedinga

205

35

17.1%

 Did not inform the woman what will happen before conducting the vaginal examinationa

205

42

20.5%

 Did not inform pregnant woman of findingsa

200

20

10.0%

 Did not explain what will happen in labor to woman (support person) at least oncea

208

43

20.7%

 Did not explain procedures to woman (support person) before proceedinga

208

32

15.4%

 Provider did not give at least one update on status and progress of laborb

2052

249

12.1%

Non confidential care

 Woman did not have audio and visual privacy during initial client assessmenta

208

121

58.2%

 Provider did not drape woman (one drape under buttocks, one over abdomen)a

208

152

73.1%

 Woman did not have her own beda

208

5

2.4%

 Provider did not use curtains or other visual barriers to protect woman during exams, births, proceduresa

206

54

26.2%

Abandonment or denial of care

 Did not encourage the woman to have a support person present during labor and deliverya

208

173

83.2%

 Provider did not encourage woman to consume fluids/food during labor at least oncea

208

70

33.7%

 Provider did not encourage or assist woman to ambulate and assume different positions during labor at least oncea

208

58

27.9%

 Provider did not ask woman which position she would like to deliver ina

207

194

93.7%

 Support person or companion for mother was not present at birthb

2071

1818

87.8%

 If support person was not present at birth: Support person was restricted from being presentb

1818

210

11.6%

 Woman requested some pain relief for her pain but was not given anythingb

118

66

55.9%

 Woman was not allowed to deliver in her preferred birthing position (if she had a preferred position)b

273

36

13.2%

 Mother and newborn were not kept in same room after delivery (rooming-in)b

1722

213

12.4%

Physical abuse

 Provider slapped, hit or pinched the woman during labor or afterc

2109

4

0.20%

  1. aapplies to first stage of labor
  2. bapplies to third stage of labor
  3. capplies to all observations