Reproductive Health

Table 2 Joanna Briggs Institute’s Quality Assessment tool to include studies in a Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis

From: Attitude towards assisted reproductive technology: acceptance of donors eggs, sperms, and embryos as treatment of human infertility: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Author, year	Q1				Q2				Q3				Q4				Q5				Q6				Q7				Q8				Q9		Overall quality result
Author, year	Y	N	U	NA	Y	N	U	NA	Y	N	U	NA	Y	N	U	NA	Y	N	U	NA	Y	N	U	NA	Y	N	U	NA	Y	N	U	NA	Y	N
(Straehl et al., 2017) [38]	√				√				√				√							√				√	√				√				√		High
(Daniluk and Koert, 2012) [7]	√				√				√				√							√				√	√				√				√		High
(Daniluk and Koert, 2012) [7]	√				√				√						√					√				√	√				√				√		High
(Hibino et al., 2013) [13]	√				√				√				√				√				√				√				√				√		Medium
(Banerjee and Singla, 2022) [16]	√				√				√				√				√				√				√				√				√		High
(Banerjee and Singla, 2022) [16]	√				√				√				√							√				√	√				√				√		High
(Afshani et al., 2016) [15]	√				√				√				√				√				√				√				√				√		High
(Afshani et al., 2016) [15]	√				√				√				√							√				√	√				√				√		High
(Ahmadi and Bamdad, 2017) [14]	√				√				√				√							√				√	√				√				√		Medium
(Ahmadi and Bamdad, 2017) [14]	√				√				√				√							√				√	√				√				√		High
(Baccino et al., 2014) [40]	√				√				√				√				√				√				√				√				√		High
(Straehl et al., 2017) [38]	√				√				√				√				√				√				√				√				√		High
(Daniluk and Koert, 2012) [7]	√				√				√				√				√				√				√				√				√		High
(Daniluk and Koert, 2012) [7]	√				√				√				√				√				√				√				√				√		Medium
(Hibino et al., 2013) [13]	√				√				√				√							√				√	√				√				√		High
(Banerjee and Singla, 2022) [16]	√				√				√				√							√	√				√				√				√		High
(Banerjee and Singla, 2022) [16]	√				√				√				√				√				√				√				√				√		High
(Afshani et al., 2016) [15]	√				√				√				√							√				√	√				√				√		High
(Afshani et al., 2016) [15]	√				√				√				√							√				√	√				√				√		Medium
(Ahmadi and Bamdad, 2017) [14]	√				√				√				√							√				√	√				√				√		High
(Ahmadi and Bamdad, 2017) [14]	√				√				√				√							√				√	√				√				√		High
(Baccino et al., 2014) [40]	√				√				√						√					√				√	√				√				√		High

Y yes, N no, U unclear, NA not applicable, < 60% low, 60–80% medium, > 80% high quality

Back to article page

ISSN: 1742-4755

Contact us

General enquiries: journalsubmissions@springernature.com